September 5, 2010





more diavlogs



Starting Over
Play entire diavlog
Recorded: July 22, 2009 Posted: July 28
email
Facebook


View Thread Post Comment
thprop wrote on 07/28/2009  at  10:05 AM
Re: Starting Over (Will Wilkinson & Kurt Andersen)
I gave up after twelve minutes or so. I went ahead to listen to the keys to renewal. My head was about to explode. Why waste Will's time with such a piece of pablum. Moral decadence. Renewal. Greatness. Moving beyond. Renew. Community. Self-sacrifice.
This is the liberal equivalent of family values. A secular religion. Human history has not been pleasant - zero economic growth until 1800. (According to Gregory Clark in "A Farewell to Alms: A Brief Economic History of the World" - read the first chapter online). In the past two or three hundred years we have been stumbling ahead - two step forward, one back, a couple to each side. We don't need great prescriptions. Just make sure we can keep stumbling in a general forward direction.
View Thread Post Comment
ogieogie wrote on 07/28/2009  at  11:06 AM
Re: Starting Over (Will Wilkinson & Kurt Andersen)
Quoting thprop: I gave up after twelve minutes or so. I went ahead to listen to the keys to renewal. My head was about to explode. Why waste Will's time with such a piece of pablum. Moral decadence. Renewal. Greatness. Moving beyond. Renew. Community. Self-sacrifice.
This is the liberal equivalent of family values. A secular religion. Human history has not been pleasant - zero economic growth until 1800. (According to Gregory Clark in "A Farewell to Alms: A Brief Economic History of the World" - read the first chapter online). In the past two or three hundred years we have been stumbling ahead - two step forward, one back, a couple to each side. We don't need great prescriptions. Just make sure we can keep stumbling in a general forward direction.
Those damn liberals with their damn economic growth! Poppycock! If stagnation was good enough for Herbert Hoover it's good enough period!
View Thread Post Comment
I'm SO awesome! wrote on 07/28/2009  at  11:17 AM
Re: Starting Over (Will Wilkinson & Kurt Andersen)
i thought this was pretty good. what was so ideological about it? pretty much is a longer version of this really simple one the Economist gave today:
http://audiovideo.economist.com/?fr_...=features_box4
i only watched half but it seemed pretty decent to me.
View Thread Post Comment
Gravy wrote on 07/28/2009  at  08:16 PM
Re: Starting Over (Will Wilkinson & Kurt Andersen)
The uneven delivery of both participants makes it very difficult to listen to. We can't expect Churchill on every diavlog, but Wilkinson is on often enough that he should be improving and he isn't. I don't think he cares to, which is his valid choice, but it is also a comment on what he thinks about this audience. Andersen is pretty brutal, too.
View Thread Post Comment
Namazu wrote on 07/28/2009  at  08:40 PM
Re: Starting Over (Will Wilkinson & Kurt Andersen)
I'm really looking forward to not reading this guy's book. Financial bubbles have been around since the dawn of finance, accompanied by social manifestations that are remarkably familiar each time. The one unique feature of the most recent one is its magnitude--a result of globalization and high-tech financial engineeering. But of course, when a baby boomer farts for the first time, he thinks he's invented the fart. I urge hungry minds out there to ignore this brain fart and go directly to Kindleberger or Galbraith, for example.
View Thread Post Comment
mmacklem wrote on 07/28/2009  at  08:55 PM
Some dingalink highlights
Did I say that or think that?
And which Party would that be?
An image I'd like out of my head
Don't let Mickey see this!
View Thread Post Comment
mmacklem wrote on 07/29/2009  at  05:58 AM
Two more dingalinks
bhtv experiments with non-English programming
bhtv ringtone: contemporary America edition
View Thread Post Comment
claymisher wrote on 07/29/2009  at  11:26 AM
Re: Some dingalink highlights
Quoting mmacklem: Did I say that or think that?
Oh Will, don't kid yourself, you'd be lost without the wingnut welfare.
View Thread Post Comment
Namazu wrote on 07/29/2009  at  12:34 PM
Re: Starting Over (Will Wilkinson & Kurt Andersen)
Come to think of it, is there someone at bhtv hq assigning these book interviews, and if so, could they be a little more discriminating? This doesn't seem like the kind of thing that would interest Will--nor does he seem to be terribly interested, despite his best efforts. The same thought occurred to me when Ann Althouse was interviewing the Snuggie(TM) guy. http://bloggingheads.tv/diavlogs/20664
View Thread Post Comment
a Duoist wrote on 07/29/2009  at  11:11 PM
Re: Starting Over (Will Wilkinson & Kurt Andersen)
"Renewal"? Oh, dear. The 'renewal' frames the enduring influence of Calvinism in Bible Belt America, and is the whipping influence of Hitler's Nazism and today's Salafism and jihadism. The greatest proponent of 'renewal' in the world today is Osama bin Laden, now that Khomeini is no longer preaching his particular brand of "renewal."
The call for 'renewal' represents a psychology soured on existing reality, and so looks back over its shoulder into the distant past to find some feature of a long-lost 'golden age' to be resurrected in the future. In Hayekian terms, the renewalist, the revivalist, is not forward-looking; to the palingenetic, the future is mortgaged to the past, bereft of new ideas.
The 'renewal' is a step toward intellectual stagnation, not toward anabolic life.
View Thread Post Comment
rfrobison wrote on 07/29/2009  at  11:25 PM
Re: Starting Over (Will Wilkinson & Kurt Andersen)
Quoting a Duoist: "Renewal"? Oh, dear. The 'renewal' frames the enduring influence of Calvinism in Bible Belt America, and is the whipping influence of Hitler's Nazism and today's Salafism and jihadism. The greatest proponent of 'renewal' in the world today is Osama bin Laden, now that Khomeini is no longer preaching his particular brand of "renewal."
The call for 'renewal' represents a psychology soured on existing reality, and so looks back over its shoulder into the distant past to find some feature of a long-lost 'golden age' to be resurrected in the future. In Hayekian terms, the renewalist, the revivalist, is not forward-looking; to the palingenetic, the future is mortgaged to the past, bereft of new ideas.
The 'renewal' is a step toward intellectual stagnation, not toward anabolic life.
No "grand renewal opening" sales for you, I guess. What do you mean by "anabolic life," by the way? My online dictionary says something about metabolism...And of course I've heard of anabolic steroids. Are you saying I'll never hit like Mark McGwire unless I give up my quest for renewal?




Bokonon: Jim invokes the Powell Doctrine in the war against Alzheimer's. 

look: What do Bob and Byron have in common? 

rcocean: Cats LOL. 

ledocs: Bob’s use of praeteritio here could have been more subtle. 

Bokonon: I think this little snippet shows just how much Bob has grown since he read my post. 

listener: I’ll be here all week, folks. And don’t forget to tip your waitress! 

Bokonon: We’ve been suspecting this for quite a while now. 

graz: Hey … preach it if you feel so inclined! 

sapeye: Apparently John doesn’t completely agree with Maureen Dowd. 

Bokonon: The Self-Reflexive Scandal. 

uncle ebeneezer: New Talking Mickey Kaus Doll! Just pull the string and it says.... 

Simon Willard: My big chance to engage Bob in a substantive discussion, and this is what I get. 

chamblee54: The acronym for this is wiz. 

Bokonon: Bob throws down the gauntlet with a very techie euphemism in the wankfest war. 

graz: The video equivalent of the godfather kiss of death. 

Ocean: I couldn’t refute Michelle G’s description of parenthood. 

propagandhi: The ev psych dissection of Chris Bosh. 

Bokonon: The origin of Norman Bates. 

T.G.G.P : Methinks she doth protest too much. Did that laugh sound forced to anyone else? 

uncle ebeneezer: McChrystal ... or Phil Jackson? 

uncle ebeneezer: No wonder we’ve all been acting so impulsively since Bob asked us not to use sarcasm! 

bjkeefe: Censorship! or, the new BhTV tagline? 

graz: A telling slip. 

listener: FDR: The real Miracle Worker. 

Simon Willard: I think I learned a new word. 

podcasts

audio (iTunes)
audio (other feed)
video (iTunes)
video (other feed)

follow us

RSS
Facebook
Twitter

store


Buy Bloggingheads T-shirts and mugs at CafePress

mailing list

Get a notification when a new diavlog is posted

contact